GHG Protocol Project-Based Accounting: Why Policymakers and Corporate Buyers Are Paying Attention

Published on 20 January 2026

Himaya Sewwandi - RE24

Himaya Sewwandi
Project Manager

As electricity systems decarbonise, climate reporting and procurement frameworks are under growing pressure to answer a simple but critical question: 

Are our actions actually reducing emissions on the grid? 

Project-based accounting, also referred to as consequential accounting or intervention accounting, has emerged as a key method for answering this question, particularly in the electricity sector. It is now central to ongoing discussions within the GHG Protocol, as stakeholders consider how to better reflect the real-world impacts of electricity procurement and policy interventions. 

What Is Project-Based (Consequential) Accounting?

Project-based accounting estimates the change in greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions caused by a specific project, action, or intervention, relative to a counterfactual baseline. A credible estimate of what would have happened without that action. 

In the electricity sector, this typically means comparing: 

  • Emissions in a baseline scenario (no project), and 
  • Emissions in a project scenario (with the project in place). 

The difference between the two represents the project’s emissions impact, often expressed as avoided or reduced emissions. 

Importantly, project-based accounting evaluates system-wide impacts, rather than emissions within a single organisation’s operational or value-chain boundary. It does not ask “what emissions do I own?” but rather “what emissions did this action change?” 

The rules and procedures for this approach are set out in: 

  • the GHG Protocol for Project Accounting, 
  • sector-specific guidance such as the Guidelines for Quantifying GHG Reductions from Grid-Connected Electricity Projects, and 
  • complementary resources including LULUCF project accounting guidance. 

The GHG Protocol Public Consultations

Project-based accounting is now firmly on the agenda of the GHG Protocol’s standards update process.

Public consultation is a core part of the GHG Protocol’s standard development and revision procedure, providing stakeholders with an opportunity to contribute input on key methodological questions that will shape future corporate and policy-driven climate reporting.

Two public consultations are currently underway:

  • Updates to the Scope 2 Guidance (2015), which address inventory (attributional) accounting; and

  • Electricity-Sector Consequential Methods, which focus on estimating avoided emissions from electricity-sector actions and inform the Actions and Market Instruments workstream.

The 60-day consultation period began on October 20, 2025, and has been extended to January 31, 2026.

In this context, RE24 is sharing its recommendations specifically on the Electricity-Sector Consequential Methods consultation, drawing on our experience with grid-aware procurement, hourly matching, and real-world PPA implementation. Our input focuses on ensuring that consequential methods are technically robust, practically implementable, and aligned with how electricity systems actually operate.

Together, these consultations reflect a growing recognition that:

  • inventory reporting alone is not sufficient to assess climate impact, and

  • project-based methods must be credible, practical, and clearly distinguished from corporate GHG inventories.

How Project Accounting Differs from Inventory (Scope 2) Accounting

Two distinctions are especially important for policymakers and corporate buyers: 

01. Assessment Boundary

Inventory accounting (including Scope 2) uses boundaries defined by: 

  • organisational control or equity share, and 
  • emissions occurring within scopes 1, 2, and 3. 

Its purpose is to allocate a share of total emissions to reporting entities. 

Project-based accounting, by contrast, defines its boundary around: 

  • the project or intervention itself, and 
  • all primary and significant secondary effects, regardless of who owns or controls the emitting assets. 

This allows it to capture system-wide impacts, such as displaced fossil generation or changes in future capacity build-out. 

02.Observed Data vs. Counterfactual Scenarios

Inventory accounting quantifies emissions that have already occurred, using observed activity data and emission factors. In theory, if all organisations reported perfectly, their inventories could sum to total regional emissions. 

Project-based accounting relies on counterfactual scenarios. It estimates how emissions would have evolved without the project, then compares that trajectory to what happens with the project. This makes it uniquely suited to assessing causality and impact, but unsuitable for allocating total emissions across organisations. 

In short:

  • Inventories track responsibility 
  • Projects estimate impact 

These methods answer different questions and should not be expected to do the same job. 

Why Project-Based Accounting Matters for Electricity Procurement

For policymakers, project-based accounting provides a framework to: 

  • assess whether incentives, regulations, or market instruments are actually changing grid outcomes, 
  • distinguish between business-as-usual deployment and actions that accelerate decarbonisation, and 
  • design policies that reward real system change, not just contractual compliance. 

For corporate buyers, it helps answer whether: 

  • a PPA or procurement decision enabled new generation,
  • electricity consumption is displacing marginal fossil generation, and 
  • climate claims reflect physical emissions outcomes, not just accounting positions. 

This distinction becomes increasingly important as renewable penetration rises, and annual average grid factors lose their relevance. 

The Central Role of Additionality

Project-based accounting depends on additionality, the principle that an emissions impact can only be claimed if the action would not have occurred otherwise. 

If a project is already: 

  • legally required, 
  • fully viable without buyer support, or 
  • common practice in the market, 

then attributing avoided emissions to a specific buyer or policy becomes problematic. 

As a result, additionality is typically assessed first, using tests such as regulatory, timing, financial, or common-practice screens. Only once additionality is established does it make sense to quantify emissions impacts using marginal emission rates or other methods. 

Without this step, project-based accounting risks overstating impacts and undermining trust. 

Quantifying Impacts: Marginal Emission Rates

Once additionality is demonstrated, emissions impacts are often estimated using marginal emission rates (MERs). These reflect the emissions intensity of the generators that are actually affected when supply or demand changes. 

Two broad categories are used: 

  • Operating margin rates, which reflect short-term dispatch impacts, and 
  • Build margin rates, which reflect longer-term changes in generation capacity. 

MERs can be calculated with high temporal and geographic granularity, making them well suited to: 

  • grid-aware procurement, 
  • hourly matching approaches, and 
  • evaluation of long-term structural change. 

However, they also introduce data and modelling complexity, reinforcing the need for clear methodological guardrails.

Secondary Effects: Balancing Completeness and Practicality

Project-based accounting can include secondary effects, such as: 

  • curtailment impacts, 
  • fuel supply-chain differences, or 
  • lifecycle emissions variations. 

Best practice does not require every conceivable effect to be modelled. Instead, secondary effects should be included only when they are: 

  • material to the overall result, 
  • quantifiable with reasonable confidence, and 
  • directionally robust. 

For example, if no electricity is procured during curtailment hours, the primary effect is already zero. Adding speculative secondary impacts in such cases may increase complexity without improving accuracy and can risk double counting. 

The goal is credible decision-useful results, not theoretical exhaustiveness. 

PPAs and Project-Based Accounting

Power Purchase Agreements can be compatible with project-based accounting when they play a causal role in enabling a project. Long-term PPAs often: 

  • reduce financing risk, 
  • unlock investment, and 
  • influence build decisions. 

However, not all PPAs are equal. A PPA signed after construction, or in a market where projects routinely proceed merchant, may have limited impact on grid outcomes. Project-based accounting evaluates the role of the procurement, not just its form.

Looking Ahead

Project-based accounting should not replace Scope 2 inventories. Instead, it should complement them, providing insight into what actions actually change emissions outcomes. 

For policymakers, it supports better policy design and evaluation. 
For corporate buyers, it offers a more honest lens on procurement impact. 

Used carefully, with clear additionality tests and proportionate treatment of complexity, project-based accounting can help ensure that electricity procurement contributes not just to cleaner ledgers, but to cleaner grids. 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top